Read the full analysis: AI And Entry-Level Work: A Closer Look At Graduate Job Trends on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
TL;DR
Job-ad data from the UK and Australia show weaker hiring in occupations with greater exposure to AI, including customer service and administrative work. The figures document a pattern, not proof that AI caused it: economic conditions, labour costs and other changes may also explain falling vacancies.
Job postings have fallen more sharply in occupations with greater exposure to artificial intelligence in both the UK and Australia, according to research and job-ad data reviewed by ThorstenMeyerAI.com. The pattern includes customer service and administrative work often associated with early-career roles, but the evidence does not establish that AI caused the declines.
A Bank of England staff analysis by Haley Schlicht compared UK online job adverts with an AI-exposure measure for occupations. Using ONS job-ad data through early 2026, it found adverts fell 15% in the most AI-exposed third of occupations, compared with 10% in the middle third and 6% in the least-exposed third. Customer service adverts fell 23%, while administrative adverts fell 22%.
Those are changes in online adverts, not a direct count of jobs eliminated by AI or graduates who could not find work. Schlicht wrote that evidence of AI-driven change in hiring was “considerably more tenuous than the headlines suggest” and that “confident attribution remains premature.” She cited other factors occurring around the same time, including pandemic-era over-hiring, slower economic conditions, remote work and higher labour costs.
Australia shows a similar pattern in graduate postings, according to the source material, citing Indeed data: postings fell almost 15% in 2025, with larger declines in AI-exposed jobs. But the fall began in 2023, before wide adoption of generative AI, and apprenticeship postings—described as having little AI exposure—fell 46% from their peak. These figures point to a broad hiring downturn as well as differences by AI exposure; they do not isolate a single cause.
AI and the entry level · explainer
From career pyramid to diamond
Why the first rung of the ladder is where AI could show up first, and why the cause is not settled yet.
A workforce by level (schematic)
Senior
Junior
AI takes tasks
Pyramid: many juniors at the basedoing scheduling, correspondence and routine information processing
UK job adverts: −15% vs −6%in the most vs the least AI-exposed third of occupations
Diamond: hollow at the base“centred on experienced staff”
How the squeeze could work
First jobsRoutine tasks: scheduling, correspondence, routine information processingthe base of the pyramid
AI steps inSenior workers can do more of the work that once formed the bedrock of junior hiringBank Underground
Fewer advertsUK online job adverts fell 15% in the most AI-exposed third, 6% in the leastBank Underground, ONS data
DiamondThe pyramid may turn into a diamond, hollow at the baseBank Underground
Not settledPandemic over-hiring, the business cycle, remote work and labour costs hit at the same time“confident attribution remains premature”
Source: Haley Schlicht, Bank of England, Bank Underground blog, Aug 6, 2026 (staff view, not necessarily the Bank’s), based on ONS online job adverts through early 2026; the pyramid-to-diamond idea is from research the post cites. The blocks are a schematic, not data. The question in the orange box is ours.
Graphic: Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
Pressure on the First Career Rung
The figures matter to graduates because many of the occupations with the steepest declines involve routine information processing, scheduling and correspondence. These tasks can appear in junior roles, where employees traditionally learn workplace practices while taking on work that more experienced staff delegate. If employers reduce such positions, new graduates could face fewer openings and less access to early on-the-job training.
That possibility is a concern, not a demonstrated outcome in the cited data. Job adverts are one signal of hiring demand, and an occupation’s exposure to AI does not show whether a particular employer has adopted the technology or replaced workers with it. A weaker entry-level pipeline could also affect employers over time if fewer junior staff gain the experience needed to move into more senior roles. The available figures do not yet measure that longer-term effect.
For universities and students, the debate is shifting from whether to use AI tools toward how to judge their output. Armin D. Ashenberg, a senior lecturer in law and emerging technologies at Western Sydney University, argued in The Conversation that graduates need to assess whether AI-generated work is good, identify shortcomings and improve it. That advice reflects an expert view about changing skills needs, not evidence that employers have already made those abilities a universal hiring requirement.
What the UK Measures Show
Schlicht’s August 2026 Bank Underground analysis used an occupational AI-exposure score and ONS online job-ad data. It sits within a wider UK slowdown: the Bank staff analysis said vacancies had nearly halved from their 2022 peak. Separately, the ONS estimated 691,000 vacancies in July to September 2026, 21,000, or 2.9%, fewer than in the previous quarter. The ONS said smaller firms may be holding back recruitment because of increased labour costs.
The Office for Budget Responsibility’s October 2026 forecast offers a cautious national estimate rather than a prediction of mass job losses. Its central forecast says AI could boost productivity growth by 0.2 percentage points a year by the medium term, while stressing that the scale and timing of any effect are “highly uncertain.” Citing the ONS, the OBR said 30% of businesses reported using at least one type of AI technology in September 2026, up from 15% two years earlier.
Two recent warnings helped prompt attention to the issue. Ashenberg published his discussion of graduate work in The Conversation on November 15. The Telegraph reported on November 13 that the OBR chief had warned of “very painful” AI-related job losses. The article was behind a paywall, and the source review found no matching OBR or parliamentary record or second outlet quoting the remarks directly. That warning should therefore be treated as a report by The Telegraph, not as a verified OBR statement.
““Confident attribution remains premature.””
— Haley Schlicht, Bank of England Data and Statistics Division, writing on Bank Underground
What the Hiring Data Cannot Prove
The central uncertainty is causation. The UK figures show that job adverts fell more in occupations rated highly exposed to AI, but several labour-market forces overlapped. The Australian decline began in 2023, and the fall in apprenticeships suggests weakening demand beyond roles most readily associated with AI. Neither set of figures, as presented here, identifies how many vacancies disappeared specifically because employers adopted AI.
The measures also have limits: online adverts do not capture every vacancy, actual hiring, layoffs or changes in the number of people seeking work. The source material does not provide the full methodology for the Australian figures or enough detail to compare them directly with the UK series. The reported Telegraph warning about the OBR chief is also unverified in an accessible speech, transcript or parliamentary record.
It remains unclear how quickly adoption will change work, whether AI will replace tasks or complement staff, and how effects will differ among industries and employers. The OBR itself said it would monitor emerging evidence on productivity and employment.
Evidence to Watch in Coming Reports
Further ONS vacancy releases and updated job-ad analyses can show whether the UK hiring slowdown continues and whether gaps by AI exposure persist. Future data will be more informative if it tracks hiring and employment alongside adverts, and distinguishes adoption of AI from other changes in employer demand.
The OBR said it would monitor new evidence for its productivity and employment forecasts. For graduates, universities and employers, the next test is whether demand changes for particular entry-level tasks and whether roles are redesigned around AI rather than removed. The current evidence supports watching those developments; it does not yet settle how much AI is contributing to the graduate hiring slowdown.
Key Questions
Does the data show that AI is causing graduate jobs to disappear?
No. It shows that job adverts fell more in some occupations rated highly exposed to AI, but the analysis does not isolate AI from other causes such as weaker economic conditions and higher labour costs.
Which UK occupations had the largest declines in adverts?
The Bank of England staff analysis reported a 23% fall in customer service adverts and a 22% fall in administrative adverts, using ONS online job-ad data through early 2026.
What happened to graduate job postings in Australia?
The source material, citing Indeed data, says graduate postings fell almost 15% in 2025, with a larger decline in AI-exposed jobs. The decline began in 2023, and apprenticeship postings fell 46% from their peak.
What has the OBR said about AI and jobs?
Its October 2026 forecast says AI could raise productivity growth by 0.2 percentage points a year by the medium term, but calls the scale and timing of the effect highly uncertain. The separate warning attributed to the OBR chief by The Telegraph has not been independently verified in the source review.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com